CRE Daily
Posts
NYC Backs Off Property Tax Hike — But the $12B Hole Isn't Closed Yet

NYC Backs Off Property Tax Hike — But the $12B Hole Isn't Closed Yet

Mamdani killed the 9.5% property tax hike on Tuesday — but the $12 billion hole he's trying to fill is still very much open, and the plan to close it is on thin ice.

Nina Dale
May 14, 2026

In partnership with

Good morning. Mamdani dropped the 9.5% property tax threat, but the budget math holding NYC together still needs Albany, a second-home surcharge, and a lot of political goodwill to survive contact with reality.

🎙️ No Cap Podcast — From historic bank vault gyms to luxury hotels, Equinox Co-President Jeff Weinhaus breaks down the real estate strategy, expansion playbook, and wellness trends powering one of the world’s most recognizable lifestyle brands. (No Cap podcast is brought to you by Henry)

CRE Trivia 🧠

The original Monopoly board game, published by Parker Brothers in 1935, borrowed its iconic property names from the streets of which American city?

(Answer at the bottom of the newsletter)

IN PARTNERSHIP WITH AIRGARAGE

From Fragmented Operations to Predictable Cash Flow

The Problem
BPG’s parking operations were fragmented and manual, leading to missed payments, tenant frustration, exit congestion, and a gated LPR system that created more problems than it solved.

The Solution
AirGarage replaced gates with a fully gateless system, automated billing and enforcement, and introduced demand-based pricing with real-time dashboards for visibility and control.

The Outcome
Operations became frictionless and scalable, congestion disappeared, cash flow stabilized, and BPG’s garages became significantly easier to manage—and more profitable.

*This is a paid advertisement. Please see the full disclosure at the bottom of the newsletter.

Market Snapshot

S&P 500

GSPC

7,444.25

Pct Chg:
+0.58%

FTSE NAREIT

FNER

840.13

Pct Chg:
-0.77%

10Y Treasury

TNX

4.473%

Pct Chg:
+0.002

SOFR

30-DAY AVERAGE

3.64%

Pct Chg:
-0.00

*Data as of 5/13/2026 market close.

Mamdani's Moment

NYC Backs Off Property Tax Hike — But the $12B Hole Isn't Closed Yet

Mamdani killed the 9.5% property tax hike Tuesday — but the $12 billion hole he's trying to fill is still very much open, and the plan to close it is on thin ice.

Relief for now: New York City property owners got a reprieve Tuesday when Mayor Zohran Mamdani scrapped his proposed 9.5% across-the-board property tax hike — a measure that had rattled landlords, homeowners, and credit rating agencies alike.

Zoom in: The reversal came alongside a $124.7 billion executive budget that claims to close the city's estimated $12 billion two-year deficit without cutting services or broad tax increases. Rating agencies had already moved NYC's outlook to negative after Mamdani's initial proposal, which also proposed pulling nearly $1 billion from the city's reserves.

The fix is fragile: The budget's gap-closing strategy leans heavily on $4 billion in new state aid from Albany — including $500 million from a pied-à-terre tax targeting second homes valued at $5 million or more — plus a $2.3 billion proposal to amortize city pension payments over time. None of it is locked in.

Unfinished business: The state budget remains unfinished, the pension restructuring needs sign-off from five separate funds, and the City Council still has to approve the full package. Some city officials privately project the pied-à-terre levy will generate even less than the $500 million Albany is counting on.

Investment climate: The property tax threat may be on ice, but the political appetite for real estate taxation in New York City isn't going anywhere. Ken Griffin, whose $238 million penthouse became a backdrop in Mamdani's "tax the rich" TikTok, said he's doubling down on Miami — though he remains invested in the 350 Park Avenue development. Even Trump weighed in Tuesday, warning Mamdani on radio not to drive away capital.

➥ THE TAKEAWAY

Looking ahead: The 9.5% hike is off the table, but NYC's $12 billion deficit isn't solved — it's been restructured into a set of politically fragile promises. For CRE, the near-term risk has shifted from a blunt tax increase to something harder to underwrite: a city budget that depends on Albany staying cooperative, a luxury surcharge that may underproduce, and a mayor who has made taxing real estate the centerpiece of his fiscal agenda.

INVESTOR SENTIMENT

Where Is CRE Sentiment Heading Next?

Take our Q2 2026 Fear & Greed Survey in under 5 minutes and get our 20 AI Prompts for CRE Professionals guide plus full industry sentiment results.

Reply “DONE” after completing the survey to receive your guide.

*This is a paid advertisement. Please see the full disclosure at the bottom of the newsletter.

✍️ Editor’s Picks

Simplified pipeline: If your deal lives in five different tools, it’s slowing you down. bracketONE brings everything into one platform so deals move forward instead of stalling. Spend less time managing systems and more time closing, for free. (sponsored)
Office overload: Trepp’s CMBS special servicing rate rose to 11.38% in April as distressed office loans drove a surge in transfers, outweighing resolutions across other property sectors.
Fed disconnect: Markets are increasingly questioning the Federal Reserve’s rate strategy as traditional models like the Taylor Rule suggest interest rates should be significantly higher than current policy levels.
Smarter modeling: Eight weeks of Wharton faculty teaching underwriting that holds up in IC. Real Estate Investing Certificate. Cohort starts June 8. Code CREDAILY: $300 off. (sponsored)
Data backlog: Construction backlogs hit a 10-month high in April, driven largely by data center projects that boosted large contractors while smaller firms lagged behind.
AI hesitation: CRE professionals are rapidly adopting AI for research and workflow support, but deep concerns over data quality and accuracy are limiting trust in high-stakes decision-making.
Control collapse: Blackstone abandoned its proposed $4B deal with Hong Kong’s New World Development after negotiations broke down over control of the heavily leveraged property company.

🏘️ MULTIFAMILY

Supply split: Multifamily construction is accelerating in the Northeast and South while the West pulls back below pre-pandemic levels, creating divergent rent and supply dynamics across US markets.
Price divergence: US home prices have surged far faster than apartment rents since 2020, widening the gap between ownership and renting across every major housing market.
Foreclosure feud: Developer Michael Stern sued lender Cottonwood Group over its foreclosure attempt on Miami’s $2B Mercedes-Benz-branded tower, accusing the firm of misusing confidential project information.

🏭 Industrial

Storage expansion: Heitman launched a new self-storage investment strategy backed by $275M in commitments and seeded with a 79-property portfolio spanning 16 states.
Industrial demand: U.S. industrial leasing reached 226.7M SF in Q1 2026, the strongest first quarter since 2022, driven by renewed demand and ecommerce growth, though higher energy costs pose a key risk ahead.
Power play: Roxborough Group and Paceline Investors acquired a high-power Silicon Valley R&D facility for $29.2M, targeting growing demand from semiconductor and advanced manufacturing tenants.
Power squeeze: Industrial developers and data centers are increasingly competing for limited electrical capacity as AI growth, automation, and electrification drive unprecedented demand for power infrastructure.

🏬 RETAIL

Mall rethink: Simon Property Group explored converting underperforming malls into data centers but found no viable opportunities despite surging AI-driven demand for power and digital infrastructure.
Lease truce: Saks Global and Simon Property Group settled their dispute, keeping key Neiman Marcus and Saks Off 5th stores open during the retailer’s bankruptcy restructuring.
Lease incentives: Hollywood retail is rebounding as landlords cut rents and offer stronger concessions to attract new restaurants, wellness, and entertainment tenants into vacant storefronts.
Teen controls: Mall owners are banning unaccompanied teens to curb disruptions, weighing safety concerns against the importance of attracting young shoppers to malls.

🏢 OFFICE

Office bet: Google opened its Meadow Point campus in San Jose, signaling continued investment in high-quality Silicon Valley offices despite broader portfolio reductions.
Meatpacking refi: Vornado and Aurora secured a $161M refinance for 61 Ninth Ave in Manhattan’s Meatpacking District, replacing existing debt on the fully leased Aetna-anchored office building.
Neuehouse lawsuit: Kilroy seeks $5M in back rent from bankrupt NeueHouse at its Hollywood location, with bankruptcy limiting potential recovery.

🏨 HOSPITALITY

Hotel rally: Hotel stocks surged in April, with the Baird Hotel Stock Index up 9% as broader markets rallied and stronger RevPAR trends boosted investor sentiment across hotel REITs and brands.
Menlo refi: Hotel NIA in Menlo Park secured a $110M refinancing backed by private credit, reflecting strong lender demand for well-located Bay Area hospitality assets near Meta.
Westlake renovation: NewcrestImage completed the renovation of the 293-room Ricardo Marriott DFW Westlake, updating amenities, F&B, and meeting space after acquiring the hotel in 2023.

📈 CHART OF THE DAY

The Midwest’s population “comeback” is largely driven by fewer low-income residents leaving due to affordability pressures, while high-earning, college-educated workers continue exiting the region at accelerating rates.

CRE Trivia (Answer)🧠

Atlantic City, NJ. Monopoly’s famous “Marvin Gardens” is actually a misspelling of the real neighborhood “Marven Gardens,” an error that’s remained on the board for nearly 90 years.

NYC Backs Off Property Tax Hike — But the $12B Hole Isn't Closed Yet

Mamdani killed the 9.5% property tax hike on Tuesday — but the $12 billion hole he's trying to fill is still very much open, and the plan to close it is on thin ice.

CRE Trivia 🧠